Fictional Fixation

“Every writer I know has trouble writing,” Ernest Hemingway once said. It’s a universal truth that the path to a completed manuscript is rarely smooth, and the journey is different for every writer. Some writers meticulously map out every twist and turn of their story before setting pen to paper, while others dive headfirst into their narratives, letting the characters and plot unfold organically. These contrasting approaches—plotting and pantsing—highlight the diverse methods writers use to bring their stories to life.

In this blog post, we’ll explore the intriguing world of plotting versus pantsing, helping you navigate these two popular writing processes. Whether you’re a meticulous planner or a spontaneous storyteller, understanding the strengths and challenges of each approach can be a game-changer for your writing journey. Our goal is to help you discover the process that resonates with you, enhancing your creativity and productivity.

We’ll start by defining what it means to be a plotter or a pantser, delving into the pros and cons of each method. We’ll also discuss hybrid approaches that combine the best of both worlds, offering practical tips to help you find your ideal writing process. Whether you’re just starting out or looking to refine your technique, this guide will provide valuable insights to support your creative endeavors.

Understanding Plotting

Plotting, also known as outlining or planning, is a method of writing fiction where the author meticulously plans out the storyline before diving into the actual writing process. This approach involves creating a detailed roadmap that guides the narrative from the opening scene to the closing chapter. By defining the major plot points, character arcs, and key events in advance, plotters aim to maintain coherence and direction throughout their writing journey.

Methods of Plotting

Traditional Outlines

Traditional outlining involves creating a comprehensive chapter-by-chapter or scene-by-scene breakdown of the story. Writers might draft extensive bullet points or detailed summaries for each segment of the narrative, ensuring that every plot twist, character development, and pivotal moment is accounted for before they start writing. This method offers a clear structure, allowing writers to see the big picture and the intricate details simultaneously.

Story Structure Models

Several established story structure models provide frameworks that plotters can use to craft their narratives. Some of the most popular models include:

• The Three-Act Structure: This classic model divides the story into three parts: the setup, the confrontation, and the resolution. It helps writers ensure their story has a solid beginning, middle, and end.
• The Hero’s Journey: Popularized by Joseph Campbell, this model outlines a protagonist’s adventure, from the call to adventure to the return with newfound wisdom. It’s especially useful for writers of fantasy, science fiction, and adventure genres.
• Save the Cat: Created by Blake Snyder, this model breaks down the story into 15 key beats that ensure the narrative progresses in a compelling and structured manner. It’s widely used in screenwriting but also applicable to novel writing.

Software Tools

In the digital age, many writers turn to specialized software to assist with plotting. Tools like Scrivener, Plottr, and various mind mapping applications offer features that help writers organize their thoughts, create visual representations of their plot, and store all their research and notes in one place. These tools can make the plotting process more efficient and accessible, especially for writers who prefer a visual or tech-savvy approach.

Pros of Plotting

Provides a Clear Roadmap

One of the main advantages of plotting is that it offers a clear roadmap for the writing process. With a detailed plan in place, writers know exactly where their story is headed, reducing the chances of getting lost or veering off course.

Helps Prevent Writer’s Block

By having a structured outline, plotters can often avoid the dreaded writer’s block. When you know what happens next, it’s easier to keep the words flowing, even on challenging writing days.

Ensures Plot Coherence and Consistency

Plotting allows writers to see the entire narrative at a glance, making it easier to spot inconsistencies, plot holes, or pacing issues before they become problematic. This foresight can save significant time and effort during the revision process.

Cons of Plotting

Can Be Time-Consuming

Creating a detailed plot outline can be a lengthy process, sometimes taking as much time as writing the first draft itself. For some writers, this can feel like a daunting and overwhelming task.

May Stifle Creativity and Spontaneity

Strict adherence to an outline can sometimes hinder the creative process. Writers might feel constrained by their own plans, missing out on spontaneous ideas that could enrich the story.

Risk of Becoming Too Rigid

Plotters risk becoming too attached to their outlines, making it difficult to adapt or change course if new ideas or better directions emerge during the writing process. Flexibility is key to maintaining a balance between planning and creative exploration.

Understanding the plotting method is essential for writers to make an informed choice about their writing process. By weighing the benefits and drawbacks, you can determine if this structured approach aligns with your creative style and storytelling goals.

Understanding Pantsing

Pantsing, a term derived from the phrase “writing by the seat of your pants,” refers to a writing style where authors begin their stories with little to no predefined plan. Unlike plotters who meticulously outline their narratives, pantsers embrace spontaneity and discovery, allowing their stories to evolve organically as they write. This approach can lead to a dynamic and adventurous writing experience, driven by the thrill of uncovering the plot along the way.

Methods of Pantsing

Freewriting

Freewriting involves starting with a general idea, theme, or image and letting the story unfold naturally. Instead of outlining plot points, pantsers dive straight into writing, allowing the narrative to take shape through the process. This method emphasizes a flow of thoughts and ideas without worrying about structure or coherence initially, creating a raw and unfiltered draft that can later be refined.

Stream of Consciousness

Stream of consciousness is a method where writers let their characters and plot develop organically, often delving deeply into the inner thoughts and feelings of their characters. This technique allows the narrative to flow in an unstructured manner, mimicking the natural progression of thoughts. It can lead to rich, character-driven stories with unexpected twists and turns.

Minimalist Planning

Minimalist planning involves having a loose idea or a few key scenes in mind before starting. Pantsers using this method may have a vague notion of where the story begins and ends, or a couple of pivotal moments they want to hit, but leave the details and connections to be discovered as they write. This approach provides a balance between total improvisation and some level of direction.

Pros of Pantsing

Encourages Creativity and Flexibility

One of the biggest advantages of pantsing is the creative freedom it offers. Without the constraints of a predefined plot, writers can explore new ideas, characters, and plot twists as they emerge. This flexibility can lead to a more original and innovative story.

Allows Characters and Storylines to Develop Naturally

Pantsing often results in more organic character development and plot progression. As writers let their characters guide the story, the narrative can take on a life of its own, leading to authentic and relatable character arcs.

Can Make Writing More Exciting and Unpredictable

For many writers, the thrill of discovery is a significant motivator. Pantsing can make the writing process more exciting and unpredictable, as authors are constantly surprised by where their story takes them. This sense of adventure can keep writers engaged and passionate about their work.

Cons of Pantsing

Risk of Plot Holes and Inconsistencies

Without a structured plan, pantsing can lead to plot holes and inconsistencies. As the story develops on the fly, it’s easy to lose track of details or introduce elements that don’t quite fit together, requiring significant revision later on.

Potential for Getting Stuck or Lost

Pantsers may find themselves stuck or lost at certain points in their story, unsure of how to move forward. Without a clear roadmap, it can be challenging to maintain momentum and direction, potentially leading to frustration or abandonment of the project.

May Require Extensive Revisions

The spontaneous nature of pantsing often results in a first draft that needs extensive revisions. Cleaning up inconsistencies, tightening the plot, and refining character arcs can be a time-consuming process, requiring a lot of effort to shape the initial draft into a polished manuscript.

Understanding the pantsing method is crucial for writers who thrive on creativity and spontaneity. By embracing the pros and being mindful of the cons, you can determine if this freewheeling approach suits your storytelling style and helps you bring your unique vision to life.

Finding Your Process

Finding the right writing process is a journey of self-discovery, experimentation, and adaptation. Each writer is unique, and understanding your preferences and strengths can significantly enhance your writing experience. Here’s how you can navigate the path to discovering your ideal approach.

Self-Assessment

To determine whether plotting, pantsing, or a hybrid approach suits you best, start with some introspection. Reflect on your personality and working style. Consider these questions:

• Do I prefer structure or spontaneity?
  • If you thrive on organization and planning, plotting might be your natural fit. If you love the thrill of discovery and flexibility, pantsing could be more your style.
• How do I handle uncertainty?
  • If uncertainty excites you and sparks creativity, pantsing may keep you engaged. If it makes you anxious and paralyzed, a plotted outline could provide the stability you need.
• What are my strengths and weaknesses?
  • Are you good at improvising and adapting, or do you excel at detailed planning and foresight? Understanding your strengths can guide you towards the method that leverages them best.
• What have past experiences taught me?
  • Reflect on your previous writing projects. When did you feel most productive and satisfied? When did you struggle? These insights can inform your approach.

Experimentation

Experimentation is key to finding your ideal writing process. Try both plotting and pantsing in short projects or exercises to see which method feels more comfortable and productive.

• Plotting Exercise: Outline a short story or a few chapters of a novel in detail before writing. Pay attention to how this affects your writing flow and creativity.
• Pantsing Exercise: Start a story with only a basic idea and let it develop as you write. Note how this impacts your engagement and the coherence of your narrative.

Hybrid approaches combine elements of both plotting and pantsing. For instance:

• Planting: Start with a loose outline or key plot points and allow the details to emerge as you write.
• Milestones and Checkpoints: Define major plot milestones but write freely between these points, blending structure with spontaneity.
• Outlining in Stages: Outline a few chapters at a time, write them, and then outline the next segment, allowing for flexibility and adjustment as you progress.

Case Studies

Learning from established authors can provide valuable insights into different writing processes. Here are examples of famous authors who have successfully used plotting and pantsing:

• J.K. Rowling (Plotter): Known for her meticulous planning, Rowling created extensive outlines and detailed notes for the “Harry Potter” series, ensuring plot consistency and intricate world-building.
• Stephen King (Pantser): King often writes without a detailed plan, allowing his stories and characters to develop organically. His approach emphasizes the joy of discovery and the natural evolution of the narrative.

Tips for Flexibility

As you explore and refine your writing process, remain open to adjusting your approach based on your growth and the demands of different projects. Here are some tips for maintaining flexibility:

• Stay Open-Minded: Be willing to try new methods and adapt your process as needed. What works for one project might not work for another.
• Blend Methods: Don’t feel confined to one method. Combine elements of plotting and pantsing to create a hybrid approach that suits your current project and writing style.
• Listen to Your Instincts: Trust your intuition. If you feel stuck or uninspired, it might be a sign to try a different approach or adjust your current method.
• Evolve with Experience: Your writing process may evolve over time as you gain experience and discover what works best for you. Embrace this evolution and continue to refine your approach.

Finding your writing process is an ongoing journey. By reflecting on your preferences, experimenting with different methods, learning from successful authors, and remaining flexible, you can discover the approach that enhances your creativity and productivity. Whether you’re a plotter, a pantser, or somewhere in between, the most important thing is to find what makes writing an enjoyable and fulfilling experience for you.

Hybrid Approaches

For many writers, the choice between plotting and pantsing isn’t black and white. Hybrid approaches offer a flexible middle ground, allowing you to harness the benefits of both methods. These strategies combine the structure of plotting with the freedom of pantsing, helping you find a balance that suits your unique writing style.

Planting

Planting is a blend of plotting and pantsing that starts with a loose outline and fills in details as you write. This method provides a general roadmap while allowing for creative freedom and spontaneity.

• Concept: Begin with a broad overview of your story. Identify the main plot points, key characters, and essential themes. Instead of a detailed chapter-by-chapter outline, you create a skeleton of the narrative.
• Implementation: As you write, let the story develop naturally within the framework of your loose outline. This approach allows you to discover new ideas and directions without straying too far from your intended path.
• Benefits: Planting offers the best of both worlds—structure to keep you on track and flexibility to explore creative avenues. It can help maintain coherence while allowing for unexpected twists and character developments.

Outlining in Stages

Outlining in stages involves creating detailed plans for a few chapters at a time, writing those sections, and then reassessing before outlining the next segments. This iterative process keeps your writing organized while allowing for adjustments as the story evolves.

• Concept: Instead of outlining the entire novel upfront, break it down into manageable chunks. Outline the first few chapters or the initial act, then write those sections.
• Implementation: After completing the outlined chapters, review your progress. Consider how the story and characters have developed, and outline the next set of chapters based on this new understanding. Repeat this process until the story is complete.
• Benefits: This method combines planning with adaptability. It ensures that your story remains coherent and well-paced while allowing you to incorporate new ideas and changes as they arise.

Milestones and Checkpoints

Setting key plot points or milestones and writing freely between them is another effective hybrid approach. This method provides clear goals without confining your creativity to a rigid outline.

• Concept: Identify major plot points or significant events that your story must hit. These milestones act as anchors, giving your narrative direction and purpose.
• Implementation: Write freely between these key points. Let the story flow naturally from one milestone to the next, allowing characters and subplots to develop organically. Use the milestones as checkpoints to guide your progress and ensure you stay on track.
• Benefits: Milestones and checkpoints offer structure without stifling creativity. They help maintain momentum and focus, preventing you from getting lost or straying too far from your main plot. This method also provides flexibility to explore different narrative paths and character arcs.

Hybrid approaches like planting, outlining in stages, and setting milestones and checkpoints offer versatile and adaptable frameworks for writers. By blending elements of plotting and pantsing, you can create a writing process that provides both structure and freedom. Experiment with these methods to find the balance that enhances your creativity and keeps your story on course. Remember, the best approach is the one that makes your writing enjoyable and fulfilling.

Closing Thoughts

Choosing the right writing process is a deeply personal journey that every writer must undertake. We’ve explored the structured approach of plotting, the spontaneous adventure of pantsing, and the versatile hybrid methods that combine the best of both worlds. Each method has its own set of advantages and challenges, and finding the one that suits you best can make all the difference in your writing experience.

Remember, there is no “right” way to write. What works for one writer might not work for another, and that’s perfectly okay. Your writing process is as unique as your stories, and the key is to find what makes you feel inspired and productive.

We encourage you to experiment with different methods and share your experiences in the comments below. What strategies have you tried? What works best for you? Your insights could help fellow writers on their own journeys.

If you enjoyed this post and want to stay updated with more tips, advice, and inspiration for writers, please subscribe to our blog. Your support is vital in helping us continue to provide valuable content.

If you find our posts helpful, consider donating to support our work. Every contribution helps us maintain and improve our resources for the writing community.

Don’t forget to share this blog post with your fellow writers and on social media. The more we share, the more we can help each other grow as writers.

Finally, we invite you to explore more content on our blog. Whether you’re looking for writing tips, industry insights, or creative inspiration, there’s plenty more to discover. Happy writing!

What To Read Next: